Fulfill.com
Case study

Purity Coffee Cut Fulfillment Costs by 50% with Fulfill

Purity Coffee, a health-focused organic coffee brand, outgrew self-fulfillment, brought in Fulfill for a second opinion on its 3PL search, and found its long-term partner in Fulfill’s top recommendation.

In this story
  • Brian LudviksenDirector of Operations
Fulfill 3PL Advisor
Someone making coffee in a home kitchen, with a bag of Purity Coffee on the counter
A bag of Purity Coffee on a kitchen counter. Photo: puritycoffee.com
Purity Coffee
A bag of Purity Coffee on a kitchen counter. Photo: puritycoffee.com

Outcomes

50%

Reduction in fulfillment costs

99.9%

Order accuracy rate

60%

Improvement in shipping costs

The verdict
I would highly recommend Fulfill.com. It’s worth the effort to go through and make the right decision the first time around. I speak from experience.
Brian LudviksenDirector of Operations, Purity Coffee
At a glance
Sells
Certified organic, specialty-grade coffee roasted for health
Starting point
About six years of self-fulfillment, sometimes one to two weeks behind at peak
Matched with
Shipfusion

Purity Coffee is a health-focused, direct-to-consumer coffee brand on a mission to improve the world’s health through coffee. It uses peer-reviewed research to craft certified organic, specialty-grade blends roasted to preserve antioxidants. With roughly 40% year-over-year growth, Purity needed fulfillment that could keep up.

Challenge

Purity Coffee was growing 40% a year, and in-house fulfillment couldn’t keep up

“We had been doing self-fulfillment for about six years and we were starting to hit some bottlenecks during our peak periods. Our surges would put us sometimes one or two weeks behind in fulfillment.”
Brian LudviksenDirector of Operations, Purity Coffee

For about six years, Purity packed and shipped its own orders. The team was good at it, processing orders by hand efficiently for most of the year. But with roughly 40% year-over-year growth, the volume kept climbing faster than an in-house operation could scale.

Peak seasons put orders weeks behind

The breaking points were Purity’s biggest sales moments: Black Friday, Cyber Monday and National Coffee Day. Each surge buried the team, and orders placed during the busiest weeks of the year could ship one to two weeks late. The weeks that should have won Purity new customers were the weeks it was most likely to let them down.

Doing it in-house wasn’t cheap, either

Self-fulfillment also cost more than it looked. Even the smallest orders cost Purity more than $10 to fulfill.

Well into its own search, and looking for a second opinion

By June 2024, Purity’s team had already made real progress on its own. It had met four 3PLs, collected their proposals and built its own cost model from simulated order data, and it wanted a decision by mid-July. The needs were specific:

  • Climate-controlled storage, below 75°F and 50% humidity
  • Fulfillment for both its Shopify store and Amazon FBA
  • Nationwide coverage, with room for international growth
  • High-touch service from a partner that could scale with it

Its front-runner was the proposal with the lowest price. But Purity had never hired a 3PL before, so the team wanted a second opinion on the 3PLs it was already talking to, and on any it should be considering but wasn’t.

When Purity reached out to Fulfill’s 3PL matchmaking service in June, Brian Ludviksen and Fulfill Co-Founder and COO Dan White dug into the options Purity already had. Through a curated matchmaking process, they added a handful of 3PLs that weren’t yet on the list, each offering a slightly different value proposition from the 3PLs Purity was already considering.

Solution

Fulfill helped Purity Coffee understand what it needed in a 3PL

“The first meeting was really great. We knew we were really in some good, informed, experienced hands right off the bat.”
Brian LudviksenDirector of Operations, Purity Coffee

Fulfill worked alongside Purity and the 3PLs it was considering, joining calls with each 3PL and the Purity team together. The goal wasn’t another list. Through a custom consulting process, Fulfill helped Purity dig into every option, both the 3PLs it was already talking to and the ones Fulfill had added, and narrow the field to a final two or three.

“We had never been looking for a 3PL before, so we didn’t know what we didn’t know, and Dan knew quite a lot. He was very resourceful, helpful in us basically understanding our needs even better than we did, to some degree.”
Brian LudviksenDirector of Operations, Purity Coffee

Fulfill also went through the numbers. It reviewed Purity’s order history and every proposal, and pointed out what the quotes didn’t make obvious, like the residential, fuel and peak-season surcharges missing from the lowest one. It put the quotes side by side on equal terms, then built projected-cost (pro forma) models to show which options would be the most cost-effective once risk, warehouse footprint and Purity’s needs were factored in. From Shipfusion’s footprint, for example, most of Purity’s shipments would travel to zone 4 or closer.

A great deal on paper

Shipfusion was Fulfill’s top recommendation. Purity instead chose the lowest-priced proposal on the table, from a 3PL it had found on its own. On paper, it was a sound decision: the savings looked substantial.

In practice, the numbers didn’t hold up. The new 3PL solved the original bottleneck, but mispicks and damaged parcels over 10 pounds followed, and support tickets rose 70%. The proposal hadn’t reflected how the 3PL actually performed, and Purity had no way to know that from the numbers alone. The savings up front turned into new costs on the back end.

That’s the gap Fulfill is there to close. Numbers and promises can look great on paper, so Fulfill helps brands choose a 3PL on its actual performance and experience, not just its quote. Within a year, Purity paid to leave its contract early and moved to Shipfusion, Fulfill’s top recommendation from the start.

A burlap sack of green coffee stamped USDA Organic, Bird Friendly and Rainforest Alliance
A sack of certified organic green coffee. Photo: puritycoffee.com
The timeline

From first call to the right 3PL

  1. About six years
    Self-fulfillment, sometimes weeks behind at peak
  2. June 19, 2024
    Purity contacts Fulfill with four proposals in hand
  3. June 26, 2024
    Fulfill’s shortlist, with Shipfusion as first pick
  4. After the search
    Purity goes with the lowest-cost proposal from its own list
  5. Within a year
    Purity leaves its contract early and moves to Shipfusion
In their own words
It’s worth the effort to go through and make the right decision the first time around.

Brian shares how Purity found its 3PL, and what the company learned from first choosing the option that looked cheaper on paper.

Brian LudviksenDirector of Operations, Purity Coffee
Results

Purity Coffee cut fulfillment costs by 50% and hit 99.9% order accuracy

“Our customer service levels are back where we want them. Our fulfillment rates are amazing. We’re saving significantly from when we were doing our own fulfillment.”
Brian LudviksenDirector of Operations, Purity Coffee

A few months into the new partnership, Purity’s service levels had recovered and it was saving significantly compared with self-fulfillment. Since the switch to Shipfusion, Purity and Shipfusion report:

  • 50% reduction in fulfillment costs
  • 99.9% order accuracy rate
  • 60% improvement in shipping costs
  • Packing errors and last-mile issues have practically disappeared
Side by side

Three ways Purity has shipped its coffee

Self-fulfillmentAbout six yearsThe lowest-price 3PLLess than a yearShipfusionSince 2025
Peak seasonsSometimes one to two weeks behind at peakThe original bottleneck was solvedCustomer service levels back where Purity wants them
Order qualityPacked by hand, efficient off-peakMispicks, and parcels over 10 pounds arriving damaged99.9% order accuracy rate
Customer supportNo figureSupport tickets up 70%Packing errors and last-mile issues have practically disappeared
CostMore than $10 for even the smallest ordersThe lowest quote, until reshipping, refunds and lost customers added upFulfillment costs cut by 50%
A coffee farm landscape with a shade tree
Purity Coffee beans in a bag
A coffee farm, and Purity Coffee beans in the bag. Photos: puritycoffee.com
Submit a brief

Find the 3PL that fits your brand

Tell us about your brand and our team will introduce you to 3PLs that fit your volume, channels, and specialties.

Case studies

More brands that found their 3PL

See all case studies